MacRaddle All articles
Mac Tips

I Audited Every Password on My Mac and Found Logins Older Than My Nephew

MacRaddle
I Audited Every Password on My Mac and Found Logins Older Than My Nephew

Photo: Dietmar Rabich, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons

The Number That Made Me Wince

Forty-seven. That's how many accounts were still hanging onto passwords I created back when Netflix was mailing DVDs and my ringtone was the iPhone's original marimba. I know because I finally did what we all know we should do: I ran a full audit of every login stored on my Mac.

Since Ventura-era macOS, Apple has quietly built a genuinely good password manager into the system. The Passwords app (it got its own standalone app in Sequoia) syncs everything through iCloud Keychain across your iPhone, iPad, and Mac. It also grades your homework. And my homework had a big red F on it.

Here's how I went from 47 ancient logins to a clean bill of digital health — and how you can do the same in an afternoon.

Step One: Let the Mac Do the Digging

Open the Passwords app on your Mac (or System Settings → Passwords on older versions) and click Security Recommendations. This is where Apple surfaces the ugly stuff:

My list was long enough to scroll like a feed. The breach section alone had nine entries, including a defunct shopping site I forgot existed. That's the thing about old passwords: they don't just sit there. When a site gets breached, that credential gets fed into credential-stuffing attacks that try it everywhere else you have an account.

Triage Like an ER Nurse

Don't try to fix everything at once — you'll burn out by account twelve. Instead, sort by blast radius:

Change immediately: Email accounts, Apple ID, banking, anything tied to two-factor authentication. Your email is the master key to everything else, since password resets flow through it.

Change this week: Shopping, social media, subscriptions, anything with a saved credit card.

Change eventually: That recipe site forum account from 2013 can wait. Or better yet —

Delete entirely: I found 19 accounts I hadn't touched in a decade. Instead of rotating their passwords, I closed them. Fewer accounts means less surface area. The IRS doesn't need a dormant login to a flash-sale site.

Make New Passwords You'll Never Memorize

While you're in each account, use the built-in generator. In the Passwords app or right from a Safari sign-up form, click the password field and choose Suggest New Password. You'll get a random 20-plus character string that you'll never know and never need to know — iCloud Keychain handles the remembering.

The old advice was to create "memorable but strong" passwords. That advice is outdated. Memorization is the wrong tool when you have a synced, encrypted vault in your pocket.

Where Passkeys Come In

For an increasing number of sites — Google, Amazon, Best Buy, PayPal, and plenty of US banks — you can go one better and set up a passkey. A passkey replaces the password entirely with cryptographic keys tied to your Apple account, unlocked with Face ID or Touch ID.

Why bother? A password can be phished, guessed, or leaked. A passkey can't leave your devices, so there's nothing for a breached site to lose. Where a site offers one, I set it up and then the password question becomes moot for that account.

To enable one: sign in to the site, head to its security or account settings, look for "Passkeys" or "Sign in with Face ID," and confirm. Takes about thirty seconds per site.

Automate the Hygiene So It Never Gets This Bad Again

The purge is done. Keeping it done takes three habits:

  1. Check Security Recommendations monthly. I put a recurring calendar reminder on the first Saturday of the month. Two minutes, coffee in hand.
  2. Never type a password into a signup form again. Let the generator make it. If a site doesn't offer passkeys yet, a generated password is the next best thing.
  3. Turn on two-factor authentication everywhere it's offered. The Passwords app can store verification codes too, so your codes and logins live in one place.

One caveat for the multi-ecosystem households out there: iCloud Keychain syncs only within Apple devices. If your partner is on Android or a Windows PC at work, you'll want a cross-platform manager or at least a plan for accessing those logins elsewhere.

The Weekend That Bought Peace of Mind

Total time invested: about three hours, spread across a Saturday with football on in the background. Forty-seven stale logins reduced to zero. Every financial account now has a unique, generated password or a passkey, and my Mac will flag problems before I ever have to think about them.

Your Mac already knows which of your passwords are terrible. All that's left is to look.

All Articles

Related Articles

I Ditched QuickBooks and Ran My Freelance Business on Free Apple Apps for 90 Days

I Ditched QuickBooks and Ran My Freelance Business on Free Apple Apps for 90 Days

The Little Black Box in My Closet Runs My House Now: A Mac mini Server Diary

The Little Black Box in My Closet Runs My House Now: A Mac mini Server Diary

I Talked to My Mac for a Week Straight — and My Notes App Never Saw It Coming

I Talked to My Mac for a Week Straight — and My Notes App Never Saw It Coming